Monday, December 1, 2008

12012008

Here is my research paper. It is what it is, so enjoy it if you can.
I know it is not spaced right, when I copied and pasted it, it did that. And I do have a works cited, just not going to put it on here.

Capital Punishment

Capital punishment or, the death penalty as it’s sometimes referred to, is a controversial topic in modern America. The debate is split between two sides, those who are for the death penalty, and those who are completely against it. Somewhere in between, there are a few who are for it in certain circumstances. But I will be focusing on the major arguments for and against capital punishment. Proponents for capital punishment generally argue that it deters crime, saves taxpayer dollars for prison expenses and gives closure and justice to the families of victims. On the other side, opponents argue that it is as much a murder as the crime committed by the offender, and that a life sentence is a greater punishment.

I’m going to start off with the pro-capital punishment side. Many argue that we have been using the death penalty since before we became a country, so why get rid of it now? There have been many studies done on the correlation between the death penalty, and murder rates. William Tucker’s “WHY THE DEATH PENALTY WORKS” article extensively argues this case:

“During the 1930's, murders hit an all-time high--probably as a result of Prohibition. Executions also peaked in 1935. In those distant days, people were executed fairly routinely and the number of executions generally tracked the number of murders. Over the next 30 years, both the murder rate and the number of executions declined. This could be interpreted two ways: murders declined because of some external reason (the end of Prohibition) and the number of executions fell accordingly; or the high number of executions pushed down the murder rate. Both explanations would work for the pre-1963 portion of the graph. But after 1963, something entirely new happened. Executions ceased altogether--not because murders had ceased but because of an entirely extraneous factor--the U.S. Supreme Court. In the early 1960's, the Court began its wholesale review of state capital cases, imposing various exclusionary rules for confessions and search-and-seizure and creating the lengthy--almost endless--appeals process. The immediate result was that executions virtually ended after 1964. In 1971 the justices declared all existing death penalties to be unconstitutional. This ban was not lifted until 1978. Only after a painful legislative reformulation did more than half the states impose the death penalty on murderers by the 1990's. What was the impact on murder? The results are plain to see. Beginning at almost the exact point when executions ended, murder soared to unprecedented heights. The murder rate tied the 1933 record in 1973, broke it in 1974, broke it again in 1980, and peaked a third time in 1990-92. Then suddenly it plummeted, so that by 1999 we were once again back to the levels of 1966 when murder first began its upward sweep.” Tucker. Pg.35-56

In the above article, Mr. Tucker clearly illustrates the direct correlation between the death penalty and murder rates. It can be concluded that Mr. Tucker believes that if the Supreme Court had not intervened, and left the death penalty alone, the murder rate increase would have been in proportion to the increase in population. Now, it can be argued that most murders are crimes of passion, or done in the heat of the moment. Supporters of banning the death penalty have been cited using this argument many times. That the death penalty does no good because they are not thinking about the conciseness. “Therefore it was "barbaric" to continue executing people when it couldn't produce any results.” Mr. Tucker combats this train of thought by simply stating the facts.

“Almost the entire run-up of homicide from 1965 to 1995 was in one specific category--felony or stranger murders. These are murders committed in the course of ANOTHER crime. While felony murders constituted only 10 percent of a low crime rate in 1960, by 1990 they constituted HALF the murder rate, which was itself twice as high. The rate of acquaintance murder has barely changed over the last 40 years. Almost the entire increase in homicide has been among felony and stranger murders.” Tucker. Pg.37

William Tucker shows that they are using on the statists they want, in their argument. Because it’s apparent that the death penalty works when you look at the whole picture.
Those who oppose the death penalty do so for a variety of reasons. Some cite the over 100 proven innocents of guilt by DNA testing, or that the state doesn’t have the right to take a life. Others state moral issues. Hugo Bedau explains there view best in his article “Death's Dwindling Dominion”

"Opponents of the death penalty typically rely on three main moral principles. First, there is the right to life. Even if this right is not absolute, it places a heavy burden on the practice of execution by the state. Second is the principle that the administration of any criminal-justice system must be fair. Yet fairness in the selection process--who shall live and who shall die--is routinely undermined by such widespread practices as the provision of incompetent defense counsel and racial bias, which increase the risk that innocent defendants will be executed. Third, there is the principle that governments ought to use no more violence in pursuit of a just end than is necessary to achieve that end (and there is accumulating evidence that the death penalty serves no necessary criminal-justice purpose).” Bedau. Pg.4

Opponents of the Capital punishment also believe it is a form of unchecked retribution. Mr. Bedau believes this is faulty logic; but states there intended argument;

“Retribution is another matter. Because it is not an empirical principle, retribution cannot be defended or criticized on empirical grounds. Instead, the case for retribution rests on moral considerations, chiefly the proposition that murderers deserve to die. The rebuttal from abolitionists often takes the form of a challenge: Do rapists deserve to be raped? Do kidnappers deserve to lose their children? Should arsonists have their dwellings burnt? If they should, why don't our laws reflect this fact? If they shouldn't, why do we make an exception in the case of murder? All parties to the death-penalty controversy must agree that in the vast number of cases where crimes are punished under law, there is simply no way to tell, a priori, exactly what an offender "deserves." What punishment does an embezzler deserve? How about an unlicensed deer hunter? Answering questions about desert in the abstract is virtually impossible. No wonder our criminal-justice system confines the role of desert to answering the question, who deserves to be punished? (Answer: the guilty.) That leaves the other question--what punishment does the offender deserve?--to criteria set by legislatures and courts.” Bedau. Pg.5

He makes a good point in which, why do murders received death, but rapists don’t get raped? This is a good question. I believe it to be that it’s socially acceptable. Just like no one has a problem openly chastise smokers, but it’s socially inacceptable to chastise obese people. Mr. Bedau is simply stating that, unless we are willing to administer the same punishment that criminals impact on their victims, the death penalty is a giant hypocrisy. I counter his argument with the simple fact, most rapists where raped, that’s why they now do it, just like most child molesters where they themselves molested as a child. So applying these punishments would just end up with the criminals repeating their crimes. Where as in the death penalty, the criminals can’t go out and repeat their crimes.
It’s also interesting to note how the death penalty is viewed, and used outside the United States. Jon Weinberg’s “Sword of Justice?” takes a look at the recent increase of beheadings in Saudi Arabia and some possible causes behind them. He states that there were over 150 beheadings last year. Rape, murder, apostasy, armed robbery, and drug trafficking are among the many crimes punishable by beheading in the oil-rich kingdom. He states that;

“One of the primary reasons for the recent increase may lie in the psychological implications of beheadings. Some human rights experts argue that the kingdom's powerful official clerics fear that they are losing their influence over the Saudi population. In order to achieve the fullest impact on the general populace, beheadings are often performed outside mosques in major cities after prayer services on Friday, the Muslim holy day. Much like the French use of the guillotine in the eighteenth century, a desensitized Saudi citizenry may have grown accustomed to and even expect beheadings. Repeated exposure to public beheadings has decreased their shock value and increased the public's overall tolerance to them.” Weinberg. Pg.1

Mr. Weinberg believes that in spite of the environment, there is no excuse for the lack of human rights. And that they are wrongly interpreting Muslim law.
“Social conditions also render the country particularly vulnerable to abrupt increases in fervor. Justification for capital punishment derives from the country's conservative wahhabi interpretation of Shariah, the set of Islamic religious laws. Yet these interpretations are by no means universally accepted in the Muslim world. Many clerics and scholars insist that the Quran makes no mention of the practice whatsoever. Of the roughly 57 Muslim-majority countries worldwide, only in Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Iran, and Qatar do national laws permit beheading. Moreover, Saudi Arabia is the only country that actually continues to behead its offenders, although both Iran and Saudi Arabia uphold the tradition of stoning adulterers to death.” Weinberg. Pg.2

What Mr. Weinberg fails to realize is that Saudi Arabia is home to Mecca. Therefore also home to every possible form of Islam. And to keep all these crazed radials in line, you need very harsh penalties. That is why Saudi Arabia has not fallen into chaos like Palestine, or Jordan, because they keep their people in line.
Overall the idea of Capital Punishment will be debated until the end of time. I agree the current system needs to be re-worked a little, but not done away with. I believe that we can create a system that uses DNA testing to ensure those convicted are indeed, the criminal. As William Tucker stated, “We can build a fool-proof Death Penalty.”

2 comments:

Katie said...

You have more quotes than original thought...
You think that's going to be a problem?

Benjamin said...

I dont think so, my professor is pretty lax, and I wrote it the best I know how and, like I said, it is what it is.